I’ve tried not to comment on current events, in part because I don’t want to be dull, and in part because that’s what everyone does, and I hate being commonplace. But the combination of seeing Good Night and Good Luck with the admission by the Bush administration of wiretaps (and more wiretaps) in clear violation of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (a bill passed with the express purpose of curbing this sort of presidential power) have pushed me over the edge.
I won’t say they’ve finally crossed the line. The administration crossed the line ages ago; but we’re rapidly reaching a breaking point where the executive branch is either grabbing, or thanks to a Republican controlled congress and a Democratic party with the spinal fortitude of a jellyfish, being openly granted near unchecked power in the name of a war on terrorism which is loosely defined, impossible to win, and as a result, indefinite and permanent. American citizens can be detained indefinitely without trial, judicial actions kept secret, lives can be ruined, assets seized, all under the unchallengeable rubric of national security.
In some ways, I feel that at least the surveillance aspect of these powers is inevitable, even if not directed at the whim of the executive branch. As technology improves, the act of surveillance will become increasingly transparent to the surveyed. Just as the audible clicks and tape changes of wiretaps gave way to imperceptible and seamless data extraction, so will the ability to look into our homes, our offices, and every other aspect of our lives. And unfortunate as it may be, as long as they are not actively bothered, the majority seem not to care.
But though I may be in the minority, I feel it necessary, and want, to add another voice in the wilderness, and reiterate something said by Benjamin Franklin, “Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.”
Stopping terrorists is a noble goal, but not everything should be sacrificed at its alter. There is little point in preserving the American way of life through its extinction.